Message Boards

×

Notice

The forum is in read only mode.
×
Looking for advice? Join us on Facebook

Get advice, ideas, and support from other parent group leaders just like you—join our closed Facebook group for PTO and PTA Leaders & Volunteers .

The New Texas FOOD Police

19 years 10 months ago #110314 by C. Brooks
Replied by C. Brooks on topic RE: The New Texas FOOD Police
I am for changes to our school's food program, statewide, but I always think about Texas and I tend to keep my mouth shut. I believe things are a tad over the top down there. I think that such strict policies could make things worse. What are these kids going to do with they get home? Probably pile up on junk, more than usual since it is "thrown" in there face.

KY recently passed a law that prohibits candy bars and such to be sold from snack machines. That I can handle. Not being able to celebrate a child's birthday in the traditional American way, I have a hard time with that.

My kids menu consist of 13 different meals the whole month of August. Pizza 3 times and the other choices usually have fries. They do offer salads 3 days a week at the elementaries. My son loves those, he needs those too.
19 years 10 months ago #110313 by LUVMYKIDS
I just had a long discussion with the head of our lunch program yesterday and he mentioned something about this legislation too. Thanks for posting all the links, looks like I should read up on this and see how it will affect our school. I was bugging him about serving something besides potatoes for the vegetable!

Hey Rocky, watch me pull a rabbit out of my hat.
19 years 10 months ago #110312 by JHB
Replied by JHB on topic RE: The New Texas FOOD Police
School started this week for many Texas districts. I know it's only been a few days, but what are your initial impressions of the new food policies?

As far as the lunch menus, I'm really pleased to see the changes. More baked food, very little fried. Fresh fruit, more salads and vegetables.

One of the big sticking points even the very first day was explaining to parents that they can no longer bring a class treat (like cupcakes) for birthdays.

Instead, the principal announces birthdays over the intercom and the birthday students come down to the office and get a birthday sticker and pencil.

It will be interesting to see how it goes with bakesales no longer allowed. And I know of other groups that routinely sold either ice cream or popcorn every Friday (which was a significant revenue source).

Anyone else have comments to share?

[ 08-19-2004, 10:32 AM: Message edited by: JHB ]
19 years 11 months ago #110311 by JHB
Replied by JHB on topic RE: The New Texas FOOD Police
This issue has raised mixed reviews in Texas from staunch supporters to others who feel it's an invasion of parental rights, to still others who would seek a middle ground.

As far as some background...

This is based on Federal guidelines for Food of Minimal Nutritional Value" (FMNV). So, to some degree, this is an issue in EVERY state.

Texas implemented it own strict version of this policy in the 2003-2004 school year, with additional restrictions taking place for 2004-2005.

We've already seen some compromises. For instance, the school can designate 3 times per year for holiday or other celebrations which are exempt from the rules.
www.agr.state.tx.us/foodnutrition/policy/ntn_fmnv_exemption.htm

Here are some links to other discussions we've had on this topic in the Forum this year.

www.ptotoday.com/ubb/ultimatebb.php?ubb=...f=15;t=000683#000002
www.ptotoday.com/ubb/ultimatebb.php?ubb=...;f=9;t=000594#000004
www.ptotoday.com/cgi-ptotoday/ultimatebb...t_topic;f=9;t=000468

The Center for Science in the Public Interest (aka "The Food Police") follows some of what's happening nationwide in this area. This publication - although now a year old - give some info.
www.cspinet.org/schoolfood/school_foods_kit_part1.pdf

The opposing view is pretty well represented by
the Center for Individual Freedom
www.cfif.org/htdocs/legislative_issues/f...form/food_police.htm


Last year there was an internet petition against the Texas rules, but I wasn't able to find it when I searched today.
19 years 11 months ago #110310 by Yearbookmom
Replied by Yearbookmom on topic RE: The New Texas FOOD Police
I agree 100 percent! There is no way that the state government should have ever gotten involved in this issue and I can guarantee that this policy will not solve the problem of childhood obesity. I am with you on this and THANK YOU for posting the info so we can express our thoughts to our legislators!
19 years 11 months ago #110309 by CStan
The New Texas FOOD Police was created by CStan
If you live in Texas and are at all involved in your child's school, you probably have heard by now that we have a new POLICE in our state, it's the FOOD POLICE. Texas has now passed a law that went into effect on August 1st. The revised Texas Public School Nutrition Policy significantly restricts the foods availabe on school grounds and in the cafeterias. To see the policy in full, please visit www.agr.state.tx.us/foodnutrition/policy...nutrition_policy.pdf. But the policy in a nutshell states that "an elementary school campus may not serve competitive foods (or provide access to them through direct or indirect sales) to students anywhere on school premises throughout the school day until the end of the last scheduled class. Elementary classrooms may allow one nutritious snack per day under the teacher's supervision." Nutritious snacks include but are not limited to 100% fruit juices, milk, pretzels, animal crackers, graham crackers, fruit or grain muffins, fresh fruit or vegetables, fat-free popcorn, etc. You can get the complete list at www.squaremeals.org. This restrictive policy ends the days of pizza parties, ice cream parties, donut parties or just bringing the class a cupcake to help celebrate your child's birthday. We can't even give the kids a piece of gum or a sucker under this new policy. While I would be the first to agree that we have an obesity problem in America, I do not believe this new strict policy is going to solve that problem. Our PTO has enjoyed offering different types of parties for different things throughout the year such as PTO membership, boxtop rewards, meeting AR goals, etc. and now that has all been taken away from us. I beleive, as many of our PTO members believe that this is something that should be handled at the local level, not the state level. There is no simple solution to childhood obesity, but what our children need is a common-sense approach that calls for more physical activity and better nutrition eduction, not FOOD POLICE! We are the taxpayers and we are the ones that have a relationship with our teachers, staff and kids, not the state. This "solution" that our state has come up with does nothing to teach children about enjoying food in moderation; it only adds to the already LENGTHY LIST OF WHAT THE SCHOOLS CONSIDER CONTRABAND, OFTEN MAKING THE FORBIDDEN OBJECTS ONLY MORE DESIRABLE. This policy is doing nothing but setting up a new generation of Americans who will graduate from high school having been taught how to point the finger at others and avoid taking personal responsibility.

Let's not sit back and let them do this. This is now, what will be next? What will they restrict or outlaw or require us to do next? We as Americans (land of the FREE) and concerned parents for our children's future need to stop and think about how many regulations the government has already imposed on us and will continue to impose on us in the future if we sit back and do nothing. The more we say "well, there's nothing we can do" the more rights the government is going to take away from us.

If you disagree with this new policy, please post here and email the Texas Department of Agriculture at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. and also contact Mrs. Susan Combs, our Agricultural Commissioner, at www.susancombs.com and let her know that Texas has crossed the line and we will not stand for it.

I would love to hear your comments. Thanks for your time!
Christy
Time to create page: 0.440 seconds
Powered by Kunena Forum
^ Top